AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!


Why Chesterton is needed now more than ever

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Jun 2004AD2000 June 2004 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: Pentecost: As it was in the beginning ... - Michael Gilchrist
Abortion: 'Pro-choice' issue emerges in US presidential campaign - Michael Gilchrist
News: The Church Around the World
Marriage: Statistics highlight the precarious state of marriage and family - AD2000 REPORT
Theology of the Body: Why the silence on the Church's moral teachings? - Audrey Dillon
Society: Why Chesterton is needed now more than ever - Dale Ahlquist
Education: Chavagnes en Paillers: a Catholic college with a Catholic culture - Paul Russell
The importance of beauty in the Liturgy - Christopher Pearson
Poetry: The power and beauty of religious poetry - Star-Life, Identikit, Ministers - Bruce Dawe
Poetry: The power and beauty of religious poetry - Cast fear behind thee, I am come! - Marion and Delia Craig
Letters: New Liturgy document (letter) - John Schmid
Letters: Disrespect (letter) - John Casamento
Letters: Behaviour at Mass (letter) - Michael Ryan
Letters: Options (letter) - Maryse Usher
Letter: Signs of hope (letter) - Daniel Attard
Letters: Priestly vocations (letter) - Monsignor Robert Egar
Letters: The Passion - Suffering (letter) - Dr Arnold Jago
Letters: The Passion - Not overdone (letter) - Monique Onezime
Letters: The Passion - No ordinary man (letter) - Jony Joordens
Letters: Faith and reason (letter) - John Kelly
Letters: Gospel Dating - The Jesus Papyrus (letter) - Paul R. Smith
Letters: Media Standards Australia (letter) - Denise Den-Bakker
Letters: Name changes? (letter) - Frank Mobbs
Letters: US Survey (letter) - Errol P. Duke
Letters: Catholic books (letter) - Frank Carleton
Events: Window Shopping for Non-Catholics - Fr Paul Newton
Books: The Free Press, by Hilaire Belloc - John Ballantyne (reviewer)
Books: The Outline Of Sanity, by G.K. Chesterton - Peter Westmore (reviewer)
Books: Catharine With An 'A', by Edna Keir - Joan Graham (reviewer)
Books: Looking Again at the Question of the Liturgy, Reform of the Reform? - Paul Russell (reviewer)
Books: More new titles for 2004 from AD Books
Reflection: The Holy Spirit: like a bed for the weary traveller - Fr Leo Duck

Dale Ahlquist, President of the American Chesterton Society and host of the EWTN Television series, "G.K. Chesterton: The Apostle of Common Sense", visited Australia in May as a keynote speaker at the National Chesterton Conference, held this year in Melbourne. This conference was promoted jointly by the Australian Chesterton Society and the Thomas More Centre (Melbourne).

While in Melbourne, Dale Ahlquist was also a featured speaker at the inaugural Thomas More Dinner. The present article was written for 'AD2000' following his return to the United States.

He was one of the most well-known and most beloved writers of the early 20th century, whose writings profoundly affected a wide range of leading figures from Gandhi to Michael Collins to C.S. Lewis to Fulton Sheen to Agatha Christie. He was a huge and happy and humble man, clad in a cape and floppy hat, who, when told by a young woman on the streets of London, "Everyone seems to know you Mr Chesterton!", replied with a sigh, "If they don't, they ask."

But no one seems to know who G.K. Chesterton is anymore. And they don't even ask. He should be taught in our schools, but his powerful and provocative books are utterly neglected.

And yet, if the definition of a classic is something that is quoted but never read, then G.K. Chesterton certainly qualifies as a classic. In spite of the fact that he is forgotten, his words are remembered. You see his wise and witty sayings everywhere:

"The Christian ideal has not been tried and found wanting, it has been found difficult and left untried."

"There will be more, not less, respect for human rights if they can be treated as divine rights."

"A citizen can hardly distinguish between a tax and a fine, except that the fine is generally much lighter."

"If a thing is worth doing, it is worth doing badly."

"Take away the supernatural, and what remains is the unnatural."

"Angels fly because they take themselves lightly."

Gilbert Keith Chesterton (1874-1936) was one of the most prolific writers who ever lived. In addition to the 100 books he wrote, the poetry, the detective stories, and the novels, he penned thousands of essays for newspapers and magazines in England and America.

There is simply too much here to be ignored. A giant can only remain hidden for so long. In spite of his disappearance from the curriculum, he is slowly being rediscovered outside of the academy by a new generation. What these new readers are finding is something they do not expect: a writer who seems to be writing more for our day than his own.

There is an unconscious prophetic quality to Chesterton's writing. He pointed out all the things in our world that attack the family and attack the faith. He warned of the dangers of both big government and big business, which would rob the family of its rights and its independence and its integrity. Wage slavery pulls both fathers and mothers out of the home. Public education and day care pull children out of the home. They are not raised by their parents, but by a strange collusion of public and private enterprises.

Chesterton said the obvious effect of frivolous divorce would be frivolous marriage. He warned that the next great heresy would be an attack on morality, especially sexual morality.

He predicted that the acceptance of birth control would lead to the acceptance of abortion and then infanticide. He said public education would be a failure because if education is emptied of religion, students will be only half-educated, and in effect, literally half-witted.

Educational experiments

And because of the failure of the public schools, he said that children would constantly be subjected to new educational experiments, controlled by the few, unaccountable to anyone, especially parents, and the student would continually be taught by new theories "younger than himself." He said the greatest problem would be "standardisation by a low standard."

Chesterton accurately predicted such monumental events as the rise and fall of Soviet communism, the outbreak of violence against the Jews in Europe, the beginning of World War II on the Polish border, the rise to dominance of the media, the entertainment industry, and even professional sports.

When a writer gets so many things so astoundingly right, it might be worth taking another look at him. He has proved himself trustworthy.

Most of us suffer from a peculiar blindness of not being able to see big things (just as somehow we have not been able to see Chesterton - all 300 pounds and fifteen million words of him.) We see divorce and abortion and homosexuality, but we do not see that these things are part of a much bigger problem. We see widespread poverty and obscene wealth, and we see dead-end wage slavery and runaway commercialism, but we don't see that these are part of the bigger problem. We are trying to fix small problems without fixing the big problems: the loss of faith within society and the fragmentisation of faith within the Church.

Chesterton had an uncanny ability to see the big picture. He said that in a broken society, two things happen: the vices run wild and do great damage, but the virtues also run wild and do perhaps even greater damage "because they are isolated from each other and wandering alone."

Thus, there will be some who care only for truth and others who care only for pity. But with those on the one side, "their truth is pitiless," and those on the other side, "their pity is untruthful."

Conservatives and liberals

It is hard to imagine a more concise analysis than that of the dichotomy between the conservatives and the liberals. Conservatives, in insisting on correct doctrine and theology, have often neglected compassion and social justice, which gives a lie to their theology. Liberals have done just the opposite: in emphasising social justice without the right theology, they are now defending wrongs instead of rights.

Truth and love must always go hand-in-hand, just as the two great commandments must always be remembered together: we must love God with all our being, and love our neighbour as ourselves.

We live in a broken society. Everything is broken and backwards. Our values are mixed up. All the brokenness can be traced to breaking these two commandments. Chesterton said, "When you break the big laws, you do not get freedom; you do not even get anarchy. You get the small laws."

Chesterton was trying to fix our broken society. He pointed out the fallacy of the cult of "progress," that is, of simply moving forward when we have no idea where we're going. We cannot have progress unless we have defined our goal, and then we can determine whether we are moving closer to it or further from it.

If we get off track, even slightly off track, we will get further from our goal the more we keep moving on the wrong track. That is not progress. Instead, we need to turn around and go backwards in order to get back to the point where we went wrong. Chesterton was always trying to get us to go back to first principles, to start right rather than continuing wrong.

Chesterton was an "original," in that he was trying to get us to think about the origins of things. There are three important original principles that affect everything else: the wonder and goodness of God's creation, the separation from God that came with Original Sin, and the restoration of our relationship with God that comes with Christ. Chesterton leaves no wiggle room in demonstrating the unique position of Christ in our history and culture. He defined culture as, "the healthy growing of ideas from their own original seed: and if you don't like that, you don't like civilisation. Also, it does not like you."

If the claims that the Church makes about Christ are true, then these affect absolutely everything. Logically, they are going to be part of the solution to every problem, whether social or theological. Chesterton said, "There is no such thing as a different subject." He wrote:

"You cannot evade the issue of God, whether you talk about pigs or the binomial theory, you are still talking about Him. Now if Christianity be ... a fragment of metaphysical nonsense invented by a few people, then, of course, defending it will simply mean talking that metaphysical nonsense over and over. But if Christianity should happen to be true - then defending it may mean talking about anything or everything. Things can be irrelevant to the proposition that Christianity is false, but nothing can be irrelevant to the proposition that Christianity is true".


There is a contrariness to the Faith. Chesterton said there is nothing that is not a fight. Truth is always under attack and so it must always be defended. We must love our enemies, which is really the reason for fighting them. We are not trying to crush them, we are trying to convert them. But in the meantime, we have to fight them. We are fighting the world in order to save it.

One of the greatest weapons we have is a 300 pound cigar smoking London journalist who died over 60 years ago. He spoke the truth in love. He also spiced it with humour. He said, "The test of good religion is whether or not you can joke about it."

People sometimes say to me, "We need another Chesterton." But we don't. The one we have been given is quite sufficient. His words are readily available to us. They are as timely as ever. He has not gone away. The only problem is that we have ignored him at our peril.

Recommended Reading

For an introduction to Chesterton, read G.K. Chesterton: The Apostle of Common Sense by Dale Ahlquist.

For Chesterton's Christian apologetics, read Orthodoxy, Heretics, and The Everlasting Man.

For Chesterton's social commentary, read What's Wrong with the World, and The Outline of Sanity.

For Chesterton's poetry, read the profound and moving The Ballad of the White Horse and the Annotated Lepanto.

Also, Chesterton's A Miscellany of Men, an amusing and provocative collection of essays, has just been reprinted.

And of course, don't forget the Father Brown mysteries.

All these titles are available through AD Books.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 17 No 5 (June 2004), p. 9

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004