AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!



Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Oct 2015AD2000 October 2015
Pastoral statement: Marriage Reinvented? - Bishop Michael Kennedy
Call to action: Call for urgent action on Religious Education
Pastoral visit: Pope Francis’ subtle challenge to Barack Obama - AD2000 Report
Pastoral visit: Positive outcome of Pope Francis’ visit to Cuba - AD2000 Report
APREL: Wake up the world - Religious Life back on the map - Anne Reeves
Russia: Church and State in contemporary Russia - Fr Lawrence Cross
Hebrew Catholics: “Salvation comes from the Jews” (John 4:22) - Andrew Sholl
The Rosary: The Luminous Mysteries explained - Audrey English
Letters: Audrey English responds to Dr Mobbs ... - Audrey English
Letters: A further response to Dr Mobbs ... - Anne Lastman
Letters: What is eternal life? - Francis Vrijmoed
Letters: The rights of children - Robert Bom
Books: ABORTION AND MARTYRDOM, edited by Aidan Nichols OP - Paul Simmons (reviewer)
Books: HOW THE REFORMATION HAPPENED, by Hilaire Belloc - Paul Simmons (reviewer)
Books: THROUGH THE YEAR WITH POPE FRANCIS: Daily Reflections, ed. Kevin Cotter - Paul Simmons (reviewer)
Reflection: Fruit of the Garden - Anne Lastman

Belloc’s counter-argument on the Reformation

By Hilaire Belloc.
(Tan Books. PB 223pp. ISBN 978 0 89555 465 9. Available from Freedom Publishing. Rec. Price: $17.60)

In this short book, published originally over 85 years ago, the famous English controversialist, Hilaire Belloc, presents a most interesting perspective on the Protestant Reformation – a perspective very different from most previous Protestant, Catholic and secular accounts of that great religious movement whose effects have been felt down to the present day.

This is a work of popular history, and is not to be considered a formal historical work. It has no footnotes, no list or references, and few direct quotations. It is intended to sell a story, rather than write a thesis, and should be judged in this light.

According to Protestant historians, the Reformation was an attempt by religious leaders in the 16th century to rediscover true Christianity, shorn of the false doctrines, corruption and self-serving practices of centuries of popish priests: a rebirth of Christianity in its original purity.

In the course of this, ritual and ceremony were radically simplified, prayer to the saints was abandoned, prayer for the deceased was discouraged if not forbidden, the sacraments and the Mass were abandoned, as were the devotional practices which had sustained religious life for centuries.

To many of the Catholic historians, the Reformation was quite simply the rebirth of a new heresy, like those which had afflicted the Church throughout history. The centre of this new heresy was an attack on the Church as Christ’s presence in the world, and the substitution of the right of private judgement in spiritual matters.

To secular historians, the Reformation was seen as an intellectual uprising against the tyranny of the priesthood, and a more or less inevitable consequence of the new learning which followed the Renaissance.

There are elements of all these accounts which are accurate. However Belloc argues that they underplay the most important causes of the Reformation: the condition of the Church itself.

Tracing the weaknesses in the church back to the Black Death and the weakening of papal authority during the Great Schism, when there were competing claimants to the See of Peter, then the leadership of the Church was in the hands of men who were utterly unworthy of the position which they occupied.

The moral collapse of the papacy was followed by the moral collapse of the aristocracy and the nobility.

While the Reformation was presented as a challenge to the church’s doctrines and authority, the most profound challenge was the desire of avaricious kings and princes to expropriate the resources of the church for their own personal wealth.

The reformed doctrines provided the means by which this could be achieved.

At the time when Belloc wrote this book, his argument was largely ignored. However, the more recent writings of historians like Henri Daniel-Rops and Eamon Duffy have tended to confirm Belloc’s argument.

This book is engagingly written, and for those with limited knowledge of the 16th Century history, will give a short overview of the principal causes of this event whose tragic consequences are still seen today in Europe, North America, Australia and elsewhere.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 28 No 9 (October 2015), p. 10

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004