AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!

Catholic universities and academic freedom

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Jul 1999AD2000 July 1999 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: An appeal that deserves our support
General absolutions to continue in Adelaide - AD2000 Report
News: The Church Around the World
Ecumenism: New ARCIC document on Papal authority - Peter Westmore
Statement of Conclusions: a 'politically correct' interpretation - Pastor Agnosticus
Religious education reform in the Melbourne Archdiocese under attack - John S. Webster
Liturgy: An American parish's formula for success - Judy Trajanyi
Catholic universities and academic freedom - Fr Daniel Callam
A successful French seminary that follows the Curé of Ars tradition - Francis Davidson
Jacques Maritain: modern philosophy in the tradition of St Thomas Aquinas - E. J. Borich
Reflection: John Paul II: how the arts and Christian faith nourish each other - Pope John Paul II

Some Catholic institutions look upon Rome's insistence on oaths of loyalty as undue interference in their proper functioning. This attitude fails to honour the principle that the primary responsibility for safeguarding Catholic doctrine in a region rests with the bishop of the place; he must therefore have a say, more or less formal, in the affairs of a Catholic college in his diocese. The public profession of Catholic belief which Rome wants the bishops to receive from theology professors is a minimal requirement.

The fact is that all educational institutions have something equivalent. No one would tolerate, for example, a racist or a sexist on the staff of a provincial university, or think that such "intolerance" is an illegitimate limitation of academic freedom. Similarly, when students are suffering harm from a professorial neglect of duty - absenteeism or unprepared classes - there is a veritable breach of contract on the part of the professor which the institution corrects by firing him.

These matters are treated in the near-universal mission statements that candidates have to endorse before assuming positions in universities, Catholic or not. Such agreed-upon statements enable the institution to meet its responsibilities to its clientele. A religious university makes an additional demand upon the appointee by requiring that his service to his students, mainly in his lectures, be consonant with the nature of the institution. It is no infringement of rights to protect and assure the preservation of these goals by requiring their public endorsement.

While it is true that the confines of Catholicism are broad, they are confines nevertheless. It is therefore possible for students or lecturers to come to question or even to transgress them. As educated persons, they should recognise that to reject any one principle in as tightly knit a structure as Catholicism is to bring the entire edifice crashing down. No one is required to be a member of a Catholic intellectual institution, but if he is then he must recognise when his principles or behaviour contradict what the institution stands for. Normally, such a person would withdraw voluntarily. Integrity and simple, honest self-respect require as much. Sometimes, for a number of reasons - financial, cultural, administrative, political - a person on staff will reject Catholic principles without resigning. This real possibility shows, first, the importance of hiring candidates who honour the Catholic world view. But the practical matter remains, and the specific nature of a religious institution requires an equally practical method of handling it.

Rev. Dr. Daniel D. Callam csb, was the founding editor of 'The Canadian Catholic Review' in 1983, and served in this capacity until 1997. He now teaches at the University of Saint Thomas in Houston, Texas. The above is an extract from a his article which appeared in 'The Canadian Catholic Review.'

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 12 No 6 (July 1999), p. 11

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004