AD2000 - a journal of religious opinionAD Books
Ask a Question
View Cart
Search AD2000: author: full text:  
AD2000 - a journal of religious opinion
Find a Book:

AD2000 Home
Article Index
About AD2000
Contact Us
Email Updates


Add Me
Remove Me

Subscriber Access:

Enter the Internet Access Key from your mailing label here for full access!

'Those Terrible Middle Ages', by Règine Pernoud

Bookmark and Share

 Contents - Nov 2001AD2000 November 2001 - Buy a copy now
Editorial: Synod of Oceania document imminent - 'Ecclesia in Oceania' - Peter Westmore
Tenth Synod of Bishops: Bishops called to courageous witness to the Faith - AD2000
News: The Church Around the World
A young Catholic's views on the state of the Church in Australia - James Connolly
Brisbane liturgy director calls Vatican document "a betrayal" - Michael Gilchrist
Pastoral letter: Taking up John Paul II's concerns about the Sacrament of Penance - Archbishop Barry J. Hickey
Cardinal Ratzinger's latest book-interview - 'God and the World' - Zenit News Service
Winter school: Evangelising in a "post-pagan" culture - Fr Anthony Mastroeni
Opinion: Catholics before and after Vatican II: separating fact from myth - John Young
Letters: Forgotten teachings - Fr John Speekman
Letters: Catholic women - Errol P. Duke
Letters: Immigration policy - George F. Simpson
Letters: Classification Guidelines - Mrs Carol V. Phillips
Letters: A response on the Creation of Man - Gerry Keane
Letters: Catholic teaching - John Schmid
Letters: St Thomas Aquinas - Valentine Gallagher
Obituary: Lew Bennett R.I.P.
Books: 'The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Jewish Origins of Christianity', Carsten Theide - Anthony Cappello (reviewer)
'Those Terrible Middle Ages', by Règine Pernoud - Christopher Quinn (reviewer)
Books: My Dear Young Friends: Pope John Paul II Speaks to Teens on Life, Love, Courage - Mary-Jane Donnellan (reviewer)
Books: 'Pardon And Peace: A Sinner's Guide to Confession', by Fr Francis Randolph - Christopher Quinn (reviewer)
Tapes: Thomas More Center Brisbane Winter School, July 2001
Books: 'The Glenstal Book Of Prayer: A Benedictine Prayer Book - Mary-Jane Donnellan (reviewer)
Books: 'STICKY THE DOG', by Robert Wheeler - Catherine Sheehan (reviewer)
Bookstore: New Titles from AD Books
Reflection: All Souls Day and a Christian response to bereavement - Fr Dennis W. Byrnes PP

by Règine Pernoud
(Ignatius Press, 2000, 180pp, $32.70 plus $4.40 postage.
Available from Ignatius Press, PO Box 180, Sumner Park Qld 4074, (07) 3376 0105)

Ask a sixth-form pupil studying history, or a university student, to write a paragraph about the Middle Ages. Or write one yourself. Then count the pejorative terms that the paragraph includes: chances are there will be quite a number. In current parlance, particularly in ecclesiastical circles, to assert that a position "belongs to the Middle Ages" is to damn it conclusively.

Règine Pernoud, a French medieval scholar, reacted to such groundless assumptions by writing this book in 1977. Its recent translation into English makes her popular defence of this fascinating period available.

Pernoud's analysis makes much of the essence of the period historians call the Renaissance of the 16th century onward which was, of course, a period that sought to bring about the re-birth of classical antiquity.

Yet, Pernoud argues, the Middle Ages were thoroughly civilised. Custom, not individualism, legalistic casuistry, or even the absolute will of any sovereign power, was at the heart of this civilisation. Pernoud defines custom as: "That collection of usages born of concrete acts and drawing their power from the times that hallowed them; its dynamic was that of tradition: a given, but a living given, not fixed, ever susceptible to change without ever being submitted to a particular will."

One does not need to know terribly much history to recognise that the abandoning of custom (theologically, of living tradition) by potentates formed the basis of campaigns of so-called reform from the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century, through the Enlightenment philosophers, various class revolutions and nationalistic and religious wars, to the individualistic 20th century dictators and the slightly more acceptable democrats, let alone the theologians and liturgical reformers who dismiss tradition as irrelevant.


In all these, the "particular will" of a key person or persons overrides living tradition. The strife-ridden results of such abhorrent chapters of history make the Middle Ages look like the Garden of Eden.

Not that Pernoud argues it was. She simply asserts that it had a more wholesome grasp of the relationship of man to man, man to the world, and of man and God, than does our individualistic era. She goes to some length to demonstrate that the "play of interdependences that made an extremely dense fabric of mediaeval society" included the assurance of the personal dignity and rights of the serf, the placing of duties towards those under him on the local lord, and the exaltation of women to the extent that they were certainly not second-class citizens excluded from influencing their times.

The Crusades and the Inquisitions are often held up as transparent proofs of the barbarity of the Middle Ages. Pernoud devotes a chapter to such accusations, which she confronts with an historian's perspective. Her discussion concludes with a question that puts the argument into context: "For the historian of the year 3000, where will fanaticism lie? Where, the oppression of man by man? In the 13th century or the 20th?"

This is an important polemical book. It was written well before such scholarly works as Eamon Duffy's Stripping of the Altars successfully attacked the revisionist view of medieval England as a dank papist fiefdom, and thus does not take account of this and other recent works of medieval scholarship. Yet it is a valuable primer which will serve to bring more balance to a much-maligned period of history.

Christopher Quinn is a European-based journalist.

Bookmark and Share

Reprinted from AD2000 Vol 14 No 10 (November 2001), p. 16

Page design and automation by
Umbria Associates Pty Ltd © 2001-2004